%UXJVDQYLVQಣ %UXNVDQYLVQಣ 8VHU 0DQXDO LQJ LQJ .ºOH IU\VHಣ VNDE & ) )ULGJH )UHH]HU .
,1'+2/'6)257(*1(/6( 2P VLNNHUKHG 6LNNHUKHGVDQYLVQLQJHU ,QVWDOODWLRQ .RQWUROSDQHO 'DJOLJ EUXJ 5§G RJ WLSV 9HGOLJHKROGHOVH RJ UHQJºULQJ )HMOILQGLQJ 6WºM 7HNQLVNH GDWD 2SO\VQLQJHU WLO WHVWLQVWLWXWWHU .81'(3/(-( 2* 6(59,&( %UXJ DOWLG RULJLQDOH UHVHUYHGHOH 6ºUJ IRU DW KDYH IºOJHQGH GDWD NODU Q§U GX NRQWDNWHU YRUHV DXWRULVHUHGH VHUYLFHFHQWHU 0RGHO VHULHQXPPHU 2SO\VQLQJHUQH ILQGHV S§ W\SHVNLOWHW $GYDUVHO IRUVLJWLJ VLNNHUKHGVDQYLVQLQJHU *HQHUHOOH RSO\VQLQJHU RJ U§G 0LOMº
ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ %ºUQ IUD WLO §U KDU WLOODGHOVH WLO DW I\OGH RJ WºPPH DSSDUDWHW IRUXGVDW DW GH HU EOHYHW NRUUHNW LQVWUXHUHW $SSDUDWHW NDQ EUXJHV DI SHUVRQHU PHG RPIDWWHQGH RJ NRPSOHNVW KDQGLFDS IRUXGVDW DW GH HU EOHYHW NRUUHNW LQVWUXHUHW %ºUQ S§ XQGHU §U VNDO KROGHV S§ DIVWDQG DI DSSDUDWHW PHGPLQGUH GH RYHUY§JHV NRQVWDQW /DG LNNH EºUQ OHJH PHG DSSDUDWHW %ºUQ P§ LNNH XGIºUH UHQJºULQJ RJ YHGOLJHKROGHOVH S§ SURGXNWHW XGHQ RSV\Q 2SEHYDU DO HPEDOODJH XWLOJ¨QJHOLJW IRU EºUQ RJ ERUWVNDI GHW NRUUHNW
ವ ವ ವ ವ ವ 8QGODG DW EUXJH KºMWU\NVUHQVHU HOOHU GDPS WLO DW UHQJºUH DSSDUDWHW 5HQJºU DSSDUDWHW PHG HQ IXJWLJ EOºG NOXG %UXJ NXQ HW QHXWUDOW UHQJºULQJVPLGGHO %UXJ LNNH VOLEHQGH PLGOHU VNXUHVYDPSH RSOºVQLQJVPLGOHU HOOHU PHWDOJHQVWDQGH 1§U DSSDUDWHW VW§U WRPW L HQ ODQJ SHULRGH VNDO GHW VOXNNHV DIULPHV UHQJºUHV WºUUHV RJ O§JHQ VNDO HIWHUODGHV §EHQ IRU DW IRUKLQGUH DW GHU GDQQHV PXJ L DSSDUDWHW 2SEHYDU LNNH HNVSORVLYH VWRIIHU VRP I HNV DHURVROEHKROGHUH PHG EU¨QGEDU GULYJDV L GHWWH DSSDUDW
ವ $SSDUDWHW VNDO WLOVOXWWHV VWUºP P MRUG MYI 6W¨UNVWUºPVUHJOHPHQWHW ವ 6ºUJ IRU DW SDUDPHWUHQH S§ W\SHVNLOWHW HU NRPSDWLEOH PHG QHWWLOVOXWQLQJHQV HOHNWULVNH P¨UNHY¨UGLHU ವ %UXJ DOWLG HQ NRUUHNW PRQWHUHW ORYOLJ VWLNNRQWDNW ವ 3DV S§ GX LNNH EHVNDGLJHU GH HOHNWULVNH NRPSRQHQWHU I HNV QHWVWLN QHWOHGQLQJ NRPSUHVVRU .
DIULPQLQJVYDQGHW L EXQGHQ DI DSSDUDWHW 6HUYLFH ವ .RQWDNW GHW DXWRULVHUHGH VHUYLFHFHQWHU IRU DW I§ UHSDUHUHW DSSDUDWHW %UXJ NXQ RULJLQDOH UHVHUYHGHOH ವ %HP¨UN DW KYLV PDQ VHOY UHSDUHUHU DSSDUDWHW HOOHU I§U GHW UHSDUHUHW DI HQ LNNH IDJOLJ NDQ GHW KDYH VLNNHUKHGVP¨VVLJH NRQVHNYHQVHU RJ YLO PXOLJYLV XJ\OGLJJºUH JDUDQWLHQ ವ 'H IºOJHQGH UHVHUYHGHOH YLO Y¨UH WLOJ¨QJHOLJH L §U HIWHU SURGXNWLRQHQ DI PRGHOOHQ HU EOHYHW VWDQGVHW WHUPRVWDWHU WHPSHUDWXUVHQVRUHU SULQWSODGHU O\VNLOGHU O§JHK§QGWDJ O§JHK
D3 D1 0§O W1 90 D2 ° A W2 B H1 W3 6DPOHGH P§O { 3§NU¨YHW SODGV XQGHU EUXJ t + PP : PP ' PP { PDVNLQHQV KºMGH EUHGGH RJ G\EGH XGHQ K§QGWDJHW RJ IºGGHUQH 3§NU¨YHW SODGV XQGHU EUXJ t + $ % PP : PP ' PP $ PP % PP t PDVNLQHQV KºMGH EUHGGH RJ G\EGH LQNO K§QGWDJHW VDPW GHQ QºGYHQGLJH SODGV WLO IUL FLUNXODWLRQ DI GHQ DINºOHQGH OXIW 6DPOHW SODGV S§NU¨YHW XQGHU EUXJ u + $ % PP : PP ' PP u PDVNLQHQV KºMGH E
JºU GHW PXOLJW DW IMHUQH DOW LQGYHQGLJW XGVW\U 3ODFHULQJ 0HG KHQEOLN S§ DW VLNUH DSSDUDWHWV EHGVWH IXQNWLRQ EºU GX LNNH LQVWDOOHUH DSSDUDWHW L Q¨UKHGHQ DI YDUPHNLOGHQ RYQ NRPIXUHU UDGLDWRUHU HOOHU NRJHSODGHU HOOHU S§ HW VWHG PHG GLUHNWH VROO\V 6ºUJ IRU DW OXIW NDQ FLUNXOHUH IULW RPNULQJ EDJVLGHQ DI VNDEHW 'HWWH DSSDUDW EºU LQVWDOOHUHV L HQ WºU JRGW YHQWLOHUHW LQGHQGºUV SRVLWLRQ 'HWWH DSSDUDW HU EHUHJQHW WLO DW EOLYH EUXJW YHG RPJLYHQGH WHPSHUDWXU IUD r& WLO r& 'HU NDQ NXQ JDUDQWHUHV NRUUHN
.21752/3$1(/ 1 8 7 6 'LVSOD\ .QDS WLO ºJQLQJ DI WHPSHUDWXU L IU\VHU .QDS WLO V¨QNQLQJ DI WHPSHUDWXU L IU\VHU 2. 0RGH .QDS WLO ºJQLQJ DI NºOHVNDEHWV WHPSHUDWXU 5 4 3 2 .QDS WLO V¨QNQLQJ DI NºOHVNDEHWV WHPSHUDWXU 21 2)) 'HQ IRUXGGHILQHUHGH NQDSO\G NDQ ¨QGUHV YHG DW WU\NNH S§ 0RGH RJ NQDSSHQ WLO V¨QNQLQJ DI WHPSHUDWXU VDPWLGLJW L QRJOH I§ VHNXQGHU QGULQJHQ NDQ WLOEDJHVWLOOHV 'LVSOD\ A B C D E F G Off min L K J I H $ .
7HPSHUDWXULQWHUYDOOHW NDQ YDULHUH PHOOHP r& RJ r& IRU IU\VHU RJ PHOOHP r& RJ r& IRU NºOHVNDE 7HPSHUDWXULQGLNDWRUQH YLVHU GHQ LQGVWLOOHGH WHPSHUDWXU 'HQ LQGVWLOOHGH WHPSHUDWXU Q§V LQGHQ IRU WLPHU 'HQ LQGVWLOOHGH WHPSHUDWXU KXVNHV HIWHU HW VWUºPVYLJW 7¨QGLQJ DI NºOHVNDEHW 'HW HU QRN DW WU\NNH S§ NºOHVNDEHWV WHPSHUDWXUY¨OJHU IRU DW W¨QGH NºOHVNDEHW .ºOHVNDEHW NDQ RJV§ W¨QGHV S§ HQ DQGHQ P§GH 7U\N S§ 0RGH LQGWLO GHW WLOVYDUHQGH LNRQ YLVHV 2)) ODPSHQ IRU NºOHVNDEHW EOLQNHU 7U\N
)DVW)UHH]H ODPSHQ YLVHV )XQNWLRQHQ VWDQGVHU DXWRPDWLVN HIWHU WLPHU 'X NDQ GHDNWLYHUH )DVW)UHH]H IXQNWLRQHQ LQGHQ GHQ VOXWWHU DXWRPDWLVN YHG DW JHQWDJH SURFHGXUHQ LQGWLO )DVW)UHH]H ODPSHQ VOXNNHV HOOHU YHG DW Y¨OJH HQ DQGHQ LQGVWLOOHW WHPSHUDWXU )DQ IXQNWLRQ .ºOHVNDEHW HU XGVW\UHW PHG HQ IXQNWLRQ GHU DINºOHU PDGHQ KXUWLJW RJ KROGHU HQ PHUH HQVDUWHW WHPSHUDWXU L UXPPHW 'HQQH HQKHG DNWLYHUHV DXWRPDWLVN HIWHU EHKRY HOOHU PDQXHOW 6§GDQ VO§V IXQNWLRQHQ WLO 7U\N S§ 0RGH NQDSSHQ LQGWLO GHW
$ODUPLQGLNDWRUHQ IRUWV¨WWHU PHG DW EOLQNH LQGWLO GH QRUPDOH IRUKROG HU JHQRSUHWWHW +YLV GX LNNH WU\NNHU S§ QRJHQ NQDS VOXNNHV O\GHQ DXWRPDWLVN HIWHU FD HQ WLPH IRU DW XQGJ§ IRUVW\UUHOVH $ODUPHQ VWRSSHU Q§U O§JHQ HU OXNNHW 1§U DODUPHQ O\GHU NDQ O\GHQ DIEU\GHV YHG DW WU\NNH S§ HQ YLON§UOLJ NQDS +YLV GX LNNH WU\NNHU S§ QRJHQ NQDS VOXNNHV O\GHQ DXWRPDWLVN HIWHU FD HQ WLPH IRU DW XQGJ§ IRUVW\UUHOVH $ODUP IRU §EHQ O§JH +YLV NºOHVNDEHWV O§JH VW§U §EHQ L FD PLQXWWHU W¨QGHV O\GHQ RJ DGYDUVHOVO
6NXE VNLQQHUQH LQG L VNDEHW IRU DW XQGJ§ EHVNDGLJHOVH DI DSSDUDWHW Q§U GX OXNNHU O§JHQ 7U\N GHQ IRUUHVWH GHO DI VNXIIHQ QHGDG 7U¨N VNXIIHQ XG LJHQ RJ NRQWUROO«U RP GHQ HU SODFHUHW NRUUHNW S§ E§GH EDJ RJ IRUVLGHNURJHQH 7HPSHUDWXULQGLNDWRU .ºOHVNDEHW HU XGVW\UHW PHG WHPSHUDWXULQGLNDWRUHQ IRU NRUUHNW RSEHYDULQJ DI PDGYDUHU 6\PEROHW S§ DSSDUDWHWV VLGHY¨J DQJLYHU GHW NROGHVWH RPU§GH L NºOHVNDEHW +YLV GHU YLVHV 2. $ VNDO GX O¨JJH IULVNH PDGYDUHU L RPU§GHW LQGLNHUHW DI V\PEROHW +YLV LNNH
%O¨VHUHQ IXQJHUHU NXQ Q§U O§JHQ HU OXNNHW 1HGIU\VQLQJ DI IULVNH PDGYDUHU )URVWVHNWLRQHQ HU YHOHJQHW WLO QHGIU\VQLQJ DI IULVNH PDGYDUHU RJ WLO ODQJWLGVRSEHYDULQJ DI IURVQH RJ G\EIURVQH PDGYDUHU 9HG LQGIU\VQLQJ DI IULVNH PDGYDUHU VWDUWHV )DVW)UHH]H IXQNWLRQHQ PLQGVW WLPHU IºU PDGYDUHUQH O¨JJHV L IU\VHUHQ 2SEHYDU GHQ IULVNH PDG M¨YQW IRUGHOW L GHQ WUHGMH DIGHOLQJ HOOHU VNXIIH IUD RYHQ 'HQ PDNVLPDOH P¨QJGH PDGYDUHU GHU NDQ QHGIU\VHV XGHQ DW WLOIºMH DQGUH IULVNH PDGYDUHU L OºEHW DI WLPHU VW§U
ODY WHPSHUDWXU RJ VNDEHW HU KHOW I\OGW NDQ NRPSUHVVRUHQ NºUH NRQVWDQW RJ VNDEH ULP HOOHU LV S§ IRUGDPSHUHQ , V§ IDOG VNDO GX LQGVWLOOH WHPSHUDWXUY¨OJHUHQ PRG HQ KºMHUH WHPSHUDWXU IRU DW JLYH PXOLJKHG IRU DXWRPDWLVN DIULPQLQJ RJ IRU DW VSDUH HQHUJL S§ GHQQH P§GH ವ 6ºUJ IRU HQ JRG XGOXIWQLQJ '¨N LNNH YHQWLODWLRQVULVWHQH HOOHU KXOOHUQH 5§G RP IU\VQLQJ ವ $NWLYHU )DVW)UHH]H IXQNWLRQHQ PLQGVW WLPHU LQGHQ GHU O¨JJHV PDG L IU\VHUHQ ವ ,QGHQ QHGIU\VQLQJ VNDO IULVNH PDGYDUHU SDNNHV LQG RJ IRUVHJOHV L D
+ROGEDUKHG IRU IU\VHUDIGHOLQJ 0DGYDUH +ROGEDUKHG P§QH഻ GHU %UºG )UXJW ERUWVHW IUD FLWUXV *UºQWVDJHU 5HVWHU XGHQ NºG 0HMHULSURGXNWHU 6PºU %OºG RVW I HNV PR]]DUHOOD +§UG RVW I HNV SDUPHVDQ FKHGGDU 6NDOG\U )HG ILVN I HNV ODNV PDNUHO 0DJHU ILVN I HNV WRUVN VNUXEEH 5HMHU $IVNDOOHGH PXVOLQJHU .RJW ILVN .
ವ 'HW DQEHIDOHV LNNH DW RSEHYDUH HNVRWLVN IUXJW V§VRP EDQDQHU PDQJRHU SDSD\DHU RVY L NºOHVNDEHW ವ *UºQWVDJHU VRP WRPDWHU NDUWRIOHU OºJ RJ KYLGOºJ EºU LNNH RSEHYDUHV L NºOHVNDEHW ವ 6PºU RJ RVW $QEULQJ GHW L HQ OXIWW¨W EHKROGHU HOOHU SDN GHW LQG L DOXIROLH HOOHU L HQ SRO\¨WK\OHQSRVH IRU DW XGHOXNNH V§ PHJHW OXIW VRP PXOLJW ವ )ODVNHU /XN GHP PHG HQ NDSVHO RJ RSEHYDU GHP L IODVNHK\OGHQ L O§JHQ HOOHU KYLV WLOJ¨QJHOLJH S§ IODVNHVWDWLYHW ವ )RU DW IUHPVN\QGH QHGNºOLQJ DI YDUHUQH DQEHIDOHV GHW DW
&D WLPHU IºU DIULPQLQJHQ LQGVWLOOHV WHUPRVWDWNQDSSHQ WLO HQ ODYHUH WHPSHUDWXU IRU DW RSE\JJH WLOVWU¨NNHOLJ HNVWUD NºOLQJ L WLOI¨OGH DI DIEU\GHOVH L GULIWHQ 'HU YLO DOWLG GDQQHV OLGW ULP S§ K\OGHUQH L IURVWUXPPHW RJ UXQGW RP ºYHUVWH UXP )U\VHUHQ VNDO DIULPHV Q§U ODJHW DI ULP HU PP W\NW 6OXN IRU DSSDUDWHW RJ WDJ HOVWLNNHW XG DI VWLNNRQWDNWHQ 7DJ HYW RSEHYDUHW PDG XG RJ O¨J GHW HW NºOLJW VWHG )256,*7,* +YLV G\EIURVWYDUHUQHV WHPSHUDWXU HU VWHJHW XQGHU DIULPQLQJHQ NDQ GHW IRUNRUWH G
3UREOHP 0XOLJH §UVDJHU /ºVQLQJ /\GVLJQDOHW HOOHU GHQ YLVXHOOH DODUP HU VO§HW WLO 6NDEHW HU IRU Q\OLJ EOHYHW W¨QGW 6H $ODUP IRU O§JH §EHQ HOಣ OHU $ODUP IRU KºM WHPSHUDಣ WXU 7HPSHUDWXUHQ L PDVNLQHQ HU IRU KºM 6H $ODUP IRU O§JH §EHQ HOಣ OHU $ODUP IRU KºM WHPSHUDಣ WXU /§JHQ VW§U §EHQ /XN O§JHQ .RPSUHVVRUHQ NºUHU NRQಣ VWDQW 7HPSHUDWXUHQ HU LQGVWLOOHW IRUNHUW 6H NDSLWOHW .
3UREOHP 0XOLJH §UVDJHU /ºVQLQJ 0DGYDUHU HU LNNH SDNNHW ULJಣ WLJW LQG 3DN PDGYDUHUQH EHGUH LQG 7HPSHUDWXUHQ HU LQGVWLOOHW IRUNHUW 6H NDSLWOHW .RQWUROSDQHO 0DVNLQHQ HU KHOW IXOGW RJ VW§U S§ GHQ ODYHVWH WHPSHUDಣ WXU 9¨OJ HQ KºMHUH WHPSHUDWXU 6H NDSLWOHW .RQWUROSDQHO 7HPSHUDWXU LQGVWLOOHW L PDಣ VNLQHQ HU IRU ODY RJ GHQ RPಣ JLYHQGH WHPSHUDWXU HU IRU KºM 9¨OJ HQ KºMHUH WHPSHUDWXU 6H NDSLWOHW .
3UREOHP 0XOLJH §UVDJHU /ºVQLQJ /§JHQ HU LNNH OXNNHW NRUUHNW 6H DIVQLWWHW /XNQLQJ DI O§ಣ JHQ 0DGYDUHUQHV WHPSHUDWXU HU IRU KºM /DG YDUHUQH NºOH QHG WLO VWXHWHPSHUDWXU IºU GH V¨Wಣ WHV L VNDEHW 'HU EOHY RSEHYDUHW IRU VWRUH P¨QJGHU PDG S§ VDPPH WLG 2SEHYDU I¨UUH PDGYDUHU VDPWLGLJW 7\NNHOVHQ DI ULPHQ HU PHUH HQG PP $IULP VNDEHW /§JHQ KDU Y¨UHW §EHQ IRU WLW EQ NXQ O§JHQ KYLV GHW HU QºGYHQGLJW )DVW)UHH]H IXQNWLRQHQ HU VO§HW WLO 6H DIVQLWWHW )DVW)UHH]H IXQNWLRQ 6K
67SSSRRR! BRRR! CLICK! HISSS! BLUBB! 7(.1,6.( '$7$ 'H WHNQLVNH VSHFLILNDWLRQHU IUHPJ§U DI W\SHVNLOWHW LQGYHQGLJW S§ PDVNLQHQ RJ S§ HQHUJLP¨UNHW 45 NRGHQ S§ HQHUJLP¨UNHW GHU OHYHUHV PHG PDVNLQHQ LQGHKROGHU HW ZHEOLQN WLO RSO\VQLQJHUQH UHODWHUHW WLO PDVNLQHQV \GHOVH L (8 (35(/ GDWDEDVHQ 2SEHYDU HQHUJLP¨UNHW WLO UHIHUHQFH VDPPHQ PHG EUXJHUYHMOHGQLQJHQ RJ DOOH DQGUH GRNXPHQWHU GHU IºOJHU PHG GHQQH PDVNLQH 'HW HU RJV§ PXOLJW DW ILQGH GH VDPPH RSO\VQLQJHU L (35(/ YHG KM¨OS DI OLQNHW KWWSV HSUHO
0,/-+(16<1 *HQEUXJ PDWHULDOHU PHG V\PEROHW $QEULQJ HPEDOODJHPDWHULDOHW L SDVVHQGH EHKROGHUH WLO JHQEUXJ +M¨OS PHG DW EHVN\WWH PLOMºHW RJ PHQQHVNHOLJ VXQGKHG VDPW DW JHQEUXJH DIIDOG DI HOHNWULVNH RJ HOHNWURQLVNH DSSDUDWHU .DVVHU LNNH DSSDUDWHU GHU HU P¨UNHW PHG V\PEROHW VDPPHQ PHG KXVKROGQLQJVDIIDOGHW /HYHU SURGXNWHW WLOEDJH WLO GLQ ORNDOH JHQEUXJVSODGV HOOHU NRQWDNW GLQ NRPPXQH
