Operating Guide

1/29/2021
Things to Consider and FAQs When Planning to Purchase a Safe Room
Which is better, an underground shelter or an above-ground shelter?
Studies have shown that you are just as safe in an approved/certified above-ground safe room as in a
below-ground shelter. In certain situations you could actually be safer in an above-ground shelter,
such as when there is flooding or if the door is blocked by debris with no other way out.
Cons for below-ground shelters
Susceptible to stresses and strains of the ground freezing in the wintertime
Can be forced out of the ground in areas where the water table is high
Expensive to dig if bedrock exists
Possibility of flooding from rain, broken water pipes, or a high water table
Steep, narrow stairs for entry
Pros for above-ground shelters
Little or no ground preparation required
Can be entered easily, particularly by elderly or disabled
Less chance of flooding from rain or broken pipes
Less expensive to install in most cases
Can be conveniently located within the house or structure
What is a Safe Room vs. a Storm Shelter?
There is no law that requires manufacturers to test and certify their storm shelters. Buyer Beware!
There are many shelter manufacturers out there that are not certified. The buyer should always ask if
the manufacturer’s products have been approved and verified by the NSSA (National Storm Shelter
Association).
It is logical that debris impact testing would be more important for above-ground shelters, and ground
stress testing would be more important for below-ground shelters. Since most communities would
require a building permit for such a project, a family would have to have a building inspector examine
the plans for the shelter, and what building inspectors require would probably vary from community to
community perhaps even requiring the approval of a professional engineer. The Swisher ESP Safety
Shelter does qualify as a FEMA Safe Room based upon compliance with ICC 500
1
, FEMA P-361
2
, and
FEMA P-320
3
.
The ESP Safety Shelter passed all tests at Texas Tech National Wind Institute and underwent a
rigorous design analysis to withstand 250 mph winds from any direction as generated by an EF5
tornado.

Summary of content (6 pages)