)RUP 1R &&5 3RZHUOLWHX 6Q|VOXQJD 0RGHOO QU ³ RFK XSS 0RGHOO QU ³ RFK XSS %UXNVDQYLVQLQJ 6YHQVN 6
,QQHKnOOVI|UWHFNQLQJ ,QOHGQLQJ 6lNHUKHWV I|UHVNULIWHU $OOPlQQD VlNHUKHWVI|UHVNULIWHU I|U VQ|VOXQJRU 6lNHUKHWVI|UHVNULIWHU I|U 7RUR VQ|VOXQJRU %XOOHUQLYn /MXGVW\UND 9LEUDWLRQVQLYn 6\PEROHU
6lNHUKHWV I|UHVNULIWHU .|U LQWH PDVNLQHQ XWDQ DWW KD RUGHQWOLJD YLQWHUNOlGHU %lU VNRU VRP JHU EUD JUHSS Sn KDOD XQGHUODJ 9DU I|UVLNWLJ PHG EUlQVOHW GHW lU P\FNHW HOGIDUOLJW $QYlQG HQ JRGNlQG EUlQVOHGXQN 'HQQD VQ|VOXQJD lU NRQVWUXHUDG RFK WHVWDG RFK lU VlNHU RFK HIIHNWLY I|UXWVDWW DWW GHQ DQYlQGV VWULNW HIWHU VlNHUKHWVI|UHVNULIWHUQD QHGDQ )|OMV LQWH QHGDQVWnHQGH DQYLVQLQJDU NDQ GHW UHVXOWHUD L NURSSVVNDGRU )\OO DOGULJ Sn EHQVLQ PHGDQ PRWRUQ lU LJnQJ HOOHU lU YDUP )\OO Sn EUlQVOH XWRPKX
5|M DOGULJ VQ| WYlUV|YHU VOXWWQLQJDU RFK N|U LQWH Sn VNUn 9DU P\FNHW I|UVLNWLJ QlU GX VYlQJHU L VOXWWQLQJDU )|UV|N LQWH DWW U|MD L EUDQWD VOXWWQLQJDU 6lNHUKHWVI|UHVNULIWHU I|U 7RUR VQ|VOXQJRU .|U DOGULJ VQ|VOXQJDQ XWDQ DWW VN\GG SOnWDU RFK DQGUD VN\GGVDQRUGQLQJDU VLWWHU Sn SODWV 1HGDQ ILQQV VlNHUKHWVLQIRUPDWLRQ VRP JlOOHU VSHFLILNW I|U 7RUR SURGXNWHU RFK DQQDQ VlNHUKHWVLQIRUPDWLRQ VRP LQWH ILQQV L $16, HOOHU ,62 VWDQGDUGHUQD .
/MXGVW\UND 7|P EUlQVOHWDQNHQ YLG I|UYDULQJ XQGHU OlQJUH WLG lQ GDJDU I|U DWW XQGYLND ULVNHU )|UYDUD EHQVLQHQ L HQ JRGNlQG EUlQVOHGXQN 7D XW Q\FNHOQ XU WlQGQLQJVOnVHW YLG I|UYDULQJ 0DVNLQHQ JHU HQ OMXGVW\UND Sn /Z$ 9lUGHW JUXQGDV Sn PlWQLQJDU DY LGHQWLVND PDVNLQHU HQOLJW DQYLVQLQJDUQD L (* GLUHNWLYHW ((& .
WDQQD PRWRUQ RFK WD XU Q\FNHOQ LQQDQ GX OlPQDU PDVNLQHQ ² WYnVWHJV VQ|VOXQJD 5LVN I|U IRWVNDGRU HOOHU DWW IRWHQ NDQ IDVWQD URWHUDQGH VNUXY )LQJHU RFK KDQGVNDGRU LPSHOOHUEODG (OVWDUW +HWD \WRU EUlQQVNDGRU Sn ILQJUDU RFK KlQGHU )|UOXVW DY NRQWUROOHQ |YHU PDVNLQHQ PRWOXW )UlWDQGH YlWVNRU NHPLVND EUlQQVNDGRU Sn ILQJUDU RFK KlQGHU )|UOXVW DY NRQWUROOHQ |YHU PDVNLQHQ PHGOXW /XWD LQWH EDWWHULHW 'ULYQLQJ +nOO WRUUW 6Q|VOXQJDQV VDPODUVNUXY 5|UHOVHULNWQLQJ IUDPnW .
LOO VWDUW &KRNH )UnQ VWRSS 0RWRUYDUY JDVUHJODJH 6QDEEW 1HXWUDOOlJH 6DNWD 6Q|VOXQJDQV PDWDUVNUXY LPSHOOHU 0LQVND |ND /nV 6WDUW DY PRWRU /nV XSS 6WDQQD PRWRUQ 0DQ|YUHULQJ DY E\JHO 8WNDVWDUULNWQLQJ 0DQ|YUHULQJ DY E\JHO 6QDSVSXPS VWDUWKMlOS %O\IULWW EUlQVOH
6QDSVQLQJ 5LVN I|U ILQJHU RFK KDQGVNDGRU 0DQ|YUHULQJ DY JDVUHJODJH 5LVN I|U IRWVNDGRU 0DQ|YUHULQJ DY SRZHUVKLIW 5HPGUDJQLQJ 0RQWHULQJ 2EV 9lQVWHU RFK K|JHU VLGD Sn PDVNLQHQ lU OLND PHG DQYlQGDUHQV YlQVWUD UHVSHNWLYH K|JUD VLGD YLG QRUPDO N|UQLQJ 5HVHUYGHODU %(6.5,91,1* .9$/ ,7(7 /nVPXWWUDU %ULFNRU 8WNDVWDUH gYUH KDQGWDJVVHNWLRQ .QRSSDU 2YDOD KXYXGEXOWDU %|MGD EULFNRU )MlGHU )MlGHUNnSD .DEHOMXVWHUDUH 6W\UNDEHO $19b1'1,1* 0RQWHULQJ DY XWNDVWDUH 0RQWH
0RQWHULQJ DY KDQGWDJHW .URND IDVW IMlGHUQ L GHW UXQGD KnOHW Sn NDEHOMXVWHUDUHQV lQGH )LJ 3ODFHUD GH |YUH KDQGWDJVVHNWLRQHUQDV lQGDU Sn LQVLGDQ DY GHQ QHGUH KDQGWDJVVHNWLRQHQ RFK SDVVD LQ KnOHQ )LJ )LJXU .DEHO .DEHOMXVWHUDUH = LQSDVVQLQJ )MlGHU 6lNUD NDEHOlQGHQ WLOO NDEHOMXVWHUDUHQ HQOLJW DQYLVQLQJDUQD L )LJXU P )LJXU .
+nOO VH[NDQWVEXOWDUQDV KXYXG PHG HQ VNUXYQ\FNHO Sn PP VDPWLGLJW VRP GX GUDU nW OnVPXWWUDUQD RUGHQWOLJW )$5$ 5,6.(5 8QGHU YLVVD RPVWlQGLJKHWHU lU EHQVLQ H[WUHPW OlWWDQWlQGOLJ RFK K|JH[SORVLY 9ULG XWNDVWDUHQ WLOO XSSUlWW OlJH )lVW OnVPXWWUDUQD RFK EULFNRUQD RUGHQWOLJW Sn VNUXYHQ EDNWLOO Sn XWNDVWDUHQ )LJ '(77$ .$1 ,175b))$ %HQVLQEUDQG HOOHU H[SORVLRQ NDQ VNDGD GLJ VMlOY RFK DQGUD RFK RUVDND PDWHULHOOD VNDGRU )|UH VWDUW 6c 81'9,.6 5,6.(1 )\OO WDQNHQ Sn HQ |SSHQ SODWV XWRPKXV RFK
)\OOD EUlQVOHWDQNHQ PHG EHQVLQ RFK ROMHEODQGQLQJHQ 2EV )|U VDPWOLJD DY 7RURV EHQVLQGULYQD SURGXNWHU VNDOO HQ VWDELOLVHUDUH DQYlQGDV XQGHU GULIW RFK I|UYDULQJ (Q VWDELOLVHUDUH UHQJ|U PRWRUQ PHGDQ GHQ N|UV RFK I|UKLQGUDU JXPPLOLNQDQGH KDUWVDYODJULQJDU IUnQ DWW ELOGDV L PRWRUQ YLG I|UYDULQJ (Q VWDELOLVHUDUH IXQJHUDU ElVW QlU GHQ EODQGDV PHG IlUVN EHQVLQ 2P GX DQYlQGHU PRWRUROMD DY W\SHQ 7RUR $OO 6HDVRQPHG VWDEOLOLVHUDUH I|U WDNWV PRWRUHU EHK|YHU GX LQWH WLOOVlWWD HQ VWDEOLOLVHUDUH 9,.7,*7 )\OO
)g56,.7,*+(7 5,6.(5 2P VQ|VOXQJDQ I|UEOLU DQVOXWHQ WLOO NUDIWXWWDJHW NDQ GHQ VWDUWDV RDYVLNWOLJHQ '(77$ .$1 ,175b))$ 3HUVRQVNDGD HOOHU VNDGD Sn HJHQGRP NDQ LQWUlIID 6c 81'9,.6 5,6.(1 'UD XU VODGGHQ IUnQ XWWDJHW QlU VQ|VOXQJDQ LQWH DQYlQGV % 7U\FN Sn VWDUWNQDSSHQ )LJXU &KRNH 7lQGQLQJVOnV 6QDSVSXPS 6Q|UVWDUW $NWLYHUD HOVWDUWHQ K|JVW WLR JnQJHU PHG LQWHUYDOOHU RP IHP VHNXQGHU GlU VQ|VOXQJDQ I|UVW InU YDUD Sn L IHP VHNXQGHU RFK VHGDQ DY L IHP VHNXQ
-XVWHULQJ DY XWNDVWDUH 8QGHU VQ| RFK YlGHUI|UKnOODQGHQ NDQ QnJUD UHJODJH RFK U|UOLJD GHODU IU\VD IDVW $QYlQG LQWH I|U P\FNHW NUDIW I|U DWW I|UV|ND PDQ|YUHUD UHJODJHQ RP GH IUXVLW 6WDUWD PRWRUQ RFK OnW GHQ N|UD HWW SDU PLQXWHU RP GX KDU VYnULJKHW DWW PDQ|YUHUD HWW UHJODJH HOOHU HQ GHO )|U XWNDVWDUKDQGWDJHW WLOO YlQVWHU RFK K|JHU I|U DWW MXVWHUD VQ|VWUnOHQV ULNWQLQJ )LJ 6WUnOULNWDUKDQGWDJHW |YHUVW Sn XWNDVWDUHQ VWlOOHU LQ VQ|VWUnOHQV K|MG 'UD LQWH nW VWUnOULNWDUHQV PXWWUDU I|U KnUW )RU
%lU VQ|VOXQJDQ L XWNDVWDUKDQGWDJHW /RVVD NQRSSDUQD Sn KDQGWDJHW RFK IlOO QHU KDQGWDJHW |YHU VQ|VOXQJDQ 6H WLOO Vn DWW VW\UNDEHOQ LQWH YULGHU VLJ )LJ )lVW DOOD NQRSDU VDPW OnVPXWWHUQ RUGHQWOLJW HIWHU DWW KDQGWDJHW RFK XWNDVWDUHQ KDU IlOOWV XSS 8QGHUKnOO 5HNRPPHQGHUDW XQGHUKnOO 6HUYLFH DY 6HUYLFHnWJlUG )|UVWD 9LG I|UYDULQJ 'UD nW DOOD IlVWHOHPHQW .RQWUROOHUD IlVWHOHPHQWHQ RFK GUD nW GHP RP GH lU O|VD ; ; 6W\UNDEHO .RQWUROOHUD VW\UNDEHOQ RFK MXVWHUD GHQ RP Vn EHK|YV ; ; 6NUD
2P VQ|VOXQJDQ DQYlQGV L K|J XWVWUlFNQLQJ NDQ GULYUHPPHQ EOL VOLWHQ RFK I|UORUD VLQ XUVSUXQJOLJD UHPVSlQQLQJ )HODNWLJ UHPVSlQQLQJ RUVDNDU VOLUQLQJ RFK PLQVNDU SUHVWDQGDQ XQGHU K|J EHODVWQLQJ 6OLUQLQJ NDQ LQWUlIID HIWHU WYn HOOHU WUH VlVRQJHU DY QRUPDO DQYlQGQLQJ WLOO WLPPDU 2P GULYUHPPHQ VOLUDU WMXWHU RXSSK|UOLJHQ XQGHU K|J EHODVWQLQJ |NDU GX UHPVSlQQLQJHQ JHQRP DWW IO\WWD = LQSDVVQLQJHQ WLOO QlVWD KnO WLOO K|JHU Sn NDEHOMXVWHUDUHQ )LJ /\IW DY UHJODJHSOnWHQ RFK OnW GHQ KlQJD Sn VWDUWVQ|UH
'HPRQWHULQJ DY JDPPDOW EODG 7D ERUW GH I\UD WRU[ VNUXYDUQD GH WYn KXYXGVNUXYDUQD RFK GH VH[ OnVPXWWUDUQD VRP IlVWHU EODGHW WLOO URWRUVSLQGHOQ )LJ 2EV )|U DWW XWI|UD GHQQD SURFHGXU EHK|YHU GX HQ 7 VNUXYPHMVHO 'UD XW EODGHW PHOODQ EODGVW|GHQ )LJ )LJXUH 7RU[ VNUXY /nVPXWWHU 6OLWDJHLQGLNDWRUKnO 7XQQ VLGD +XYXGVNUXY %ODGVW|G 'ULYUHPVNnSD 7MRFN VLGD 0RQWHULQJ DY Q\WW EODG %\WH DY WlQGVWLIW *UDQVND HJJHQ Sn
-XVWHUD HOHNWURGJDSHW WLOO PP )LJ µ PP P )LJXU 'UD nW VWLIWHW WLOO PRPHQW 1 P 6H WLOO DWW VNUXYD nW VWLIWHW RUGHQWOLJW RP GX LQWH KDU HQ VNLIWQ\FNHO 6lWW Sn WlQGNDEHOQ Sn WlQGVWLIWHW P )LJXU 0RQWHUD UHJODJHSOnWHQ PHG VNUXYDUQD %URPVDUP %\WH DY GULYUHP 0HOODQUHPVNLYD 0RQWHULQJVPXWWUDU I|U )MlGHU WLOO PHOODQUHPVNLYD .DEHOVNLYD .RQWUROOHUD GULYUHPPHQ I|UH YDUMH VlVRQJ RFK E\W XW GHQ RP GHQ lU VOLWH
/nW UHPPHQ JOLGD Sn URWRUVNLYDQ VDPWLGLJW VRP GX KnOOHU L GULYUHPPHQ RFK YULG URWRUQ PHG GHQ DQGUD KDQGHQ WLOOV GULYUHPPHQ YLODU KHOW RFK KnOOHW Sn URWRUVNLYDQ )LJ 0RQWHUD GHQ YlQVWUD VLGRNnSDQ RFK GUD nW IlVWHOHPHQWHQ RUGHQWOLJW PHQ GUD LQWH nW I|U KnUW 6H WLOO DWW GHQ OnQJD lQGHQ Sn IMlGHUQ WLOO PHOODQUHPVNLYDQ lU IDVWNURNDG L KXVKnOHW RFK DWW GHQ UXQGD lQGHQ Sn IMlGHUQ lU IDVWNURNDG L EURPVDUPHQ )LJ 0RQWHUD UHJODJHSOnWHQ PHG VNUXYDUQD /\IW XSS EURPVDUPHQ NOlP LKRS
352%/(0 0RWRUQ N|U RMlPQW 0RWRUQ N|U PHQ VQ|VOXQJDQ VOXQJDU XW VQ| GnOLJW HOOHU LQWH DOOV 6Q|VOXQJDQ U|MHU LQWH ERUW VQ|Q IUnQ XQGHUODJHW RUGHQWOLJW 6|VOXQJDQ GULYHU LQWH VLJ VMlOY 5RWRUEODGHQ VWDQQDU LQWH RUGHQWOLJW 0g-/,*$ 256$.(5 .255(.7,9 c7*b5' &KRNHQ lU L OlJHW 2Q )O\WWD FKRNHQ WLOO OlJHW 2II %UlQVOHV\VWHPHW LQQHKnOOHU JDPPDOW EUlQVOH 7DSSD XU RFK I\OO EUlQVOHWDQNHQ PHG IlUVN EHQVLQ LQWH PHU lQ GDJDU JDPPDO .
)|UYDULQJ 3UHSDUHULQJ DY VQ|VOXQJDQ 'UD nW DOOD O|VD VNUXYDU EXOWDU RFK OnVPXWWUDU 5HSDUHUD HOOHU E\W XW VNDGDGH GHODU 9$51,1* 5HQJ|U VQ|VOXQJDQ RUGHQWOLJW 5,6.(5 %HQVLQnQJRU lU P\FNHW EUDQGIDUOLJD H[SORVLYD VDPW IDUOLJD DWW LQDQGDV 7lFN |YHU VQ|VOXQJDQ RFK I|UYDUD GHQ WRUUW RFK GlU EDUQ LQWH NRPPHU nW GHQ /nW PRWRUQ NDOOQD LQQDQ VQ|VOXQJDQ VWlOOV LQ '(77$ .$1 ,175b))$ 2P PDVNLQHQ I|UYDUDV GlU GHW ILQQV |SSHQ HOG NDQ EHQVLQnQJRUQD DQWlQGDV RFK RUVDND H[SORVLRQ 6c 81'9,.6 5,6.
